Celebrating Meaningful Movement Analysis

Thirty-five individuals from across the nation and around the world gathered in Golden, Colorado over Memorial Day weekend to celebrate the life and work of movement analysis pioneer, Warren Lamb (1923-2014) at a seminar sponsored by Motus Humanus.

DSC00617Warren Lamb began his career under the tutelage of movement theorist Rudolf Laban and management consultant F.C. Lawrence.  Their ground-breaking work provided a basis for matching the movement traits of manual laborers to the motion factors of various factory jobs. Lamb took this work much further, to relate movement patterns to cognitive processes used in decision making at the managerial level. Over 400 companies worldwide utilized Lamb’s profiles work to select and build executive teams, with some firms employing this consulting approach continuously for three decades.

The weekend seminar sponsored by Motus Humanus incorporated sessions on Lamb’s key ideas. All the presenters were Registered Movement Pattern Analysts who had studied and worked with Lamb. Presenters included Laurie Cameron, Jagriti Chander, Alison Henderson, Charlotte Honda, Patricia Marek, James McBride, Beverly Stokes, and myself.

In addition, Motus Humanus recognized the contributions of Eden Davies with its new “Friend of Movement Study” award. Over the last 20 years, Davies has promoted Movement Pattern Analysis through writing, publishing, and other supportive efforts. The award was presented by Lamb’s daughter, Imogen Lamb, who traveled from Europe to attend the event, along with her sister Elizabeth and brother Tim Lamb.   A particular highlight was the impromptu talk Tim gave at the closing banquet in which he shared his perspective on growing up with a very unconventional father who even had an empty room in the family home dedicated to movement!

Teaching Observation Tip 5 – Discover Something

MoveScape Center

Movement analysis is not an end in itself. It is a means to an end, a way to solve a problem or discover something. One way I encourage students to apply observation and analysis is through a Challenge Session.

The Challenge Session is a carefully structured class in which students are asked to observe videotaped material and answer a question. I have chosen the material, analyzed it myself, and framed the question – ideally one that can be answered in more than one way. For example, I might use video of two people doing the same task in different ways and ask which person is most effective. The challenge to students is to analyze the material and use their movement analyses to substantiate their answers to the question. In this example, students have to define what “effectiveness” in the particular task might be and relate the movement data to their criteria.

I exercise some control over the process of the Challenge Session while leaving other choices open to students. For example, I will limit the duration of observation by allowing students to observe the video only five times (with time between to make notes). Students are free, however, to choose the movement parameters they want to focus on and to record observations in whatever way they prefer.

The observation and analysis process is completed outside of class, as students write a short paper, stating their answer to the question and supporting this with their movement analyses. When grading the papers, I check the accuracy of their observations and how they use this movement information to answer the question.

We conclude the Challenge with a class discussion when the papers are returned. This may include reviewing the video to clarify analytic details. More importantly, the discussion allows the students to share their different answers. How was “effective” defined – carefulness or speed? Which mover did they prefer? Why? What movement parameters did they choose? What did they learn from the whole experience?

Tip #5 – Challenge students to discover something.

Teaching Observation Tip 4 – Show Me

MoveScape CenterAs students are grappling with the general concepts and descriptive terms of Laban Movement Analysis, they often ask hypothetical questions. For example, “If I were on board a ship crossing the international dateline while balancing an ice cream cone on my nose, would that be lightness?”

Laban Movement Analysis may be a parsimonious taxonomy of abstract terms, but it was developed to provide an empirical description of concrete physical actions. So whenever I get a hypothetical question like the one above, I always ask the student to demonstrate. It is simply not possible to analyze a hypothetical movement accurately.

Similarly students will describe something they have seen and ask the instructor (who has not seen the event) if it was X or Y? Again, it is not possible to analyze something one has not observed accurately.

So while students need to be out in the world, watching people move and trying on their Laban glasses, this does not suffice. They must be seen seeing. They must have what they have seen confirmed by a more experienced observer.

The Embodiment Project is one assignment I have developed to address this need. Students are assigned to observe a repeated action of some sort, learn to perform it, and write an analytic description of the action. Then in class the student performs the action and discusses his or her analysis. This allows the instructor to see what the student has seen (at least approximately) and confirm or correct the student’s analysis.

Tip #4 – Make movement observation and analysis concrete so that students can be see and be confirmed and/or corrected in what they are seeing.

Teaching Observation Tip 3 – Use Video Wisely

It has taken me years to realize that Laban’s movement analysis system is abstract. The descriptive terms are quite general. Take effort – there are only four motion factors and eight effort qualities for describing any movement a human being can do. This means that the same effort quality can be in movements that look nothing alike, occur in different contexts, and are performed for different reasons.

A student can do strong movements in the studio and concretely experience the physical sensation of increasing pressure. But to transfer that “felt sense” and reliably identify the effort quality of strength in a variety of movements is quite another thing. The student really needs to build a bank of images – strength used in shoveling, strength in a stamping dance, strength in a hand gesture, strength with sustainment, etc. And this is where video can be enormously helpful when used wisely.

Using video wisely involves two things: finding clear examples and giving students an appropriate point of concentration. It doesn’t do much good to bring in a video clip and ask a group of 15 students, “What did you see?” The instructor will get 15 different answers, simultaneously raising the observation anxiety level by 200%. (I know because I have been there and done that!)

In contrast, students can be directed to look at how the weight effort is used in a video clip that has clear examples. This approach allows students to look for what is there. When they see it and identify it, the instructor can confirm their analysis. This procedure not only builds students’ confidence, it also builds an inner bank of images to which each student can refer later when observing solo.

Tip #3 – Prescreen video to find clear examples of an effort or space element, then direct students to watch for that element.

MoveScape Center

Teaching Observation Tip 2 – Rewind

Human movement exists at a perpetual vanishing point, disappearing even as it is occurring. With no fixed points, movement is devilishly difficult to observe, let alone to pin down and analyze.

Thank goodness for video recording. The rewind button makes it possible for students to see the same event repeated exactly as many times as they need. Live observation, of course, is richer. It is life size, genuinely three-dimensional, and many fine details blurred on a video recording are clearer in the flesh.

However, even simple repetitive working actions or choreographed sequences vary with each performance. I have found these subtle variations to be very frustrating for beginning observers. I still use live observation. But I supplement it with video examples. And this has never been easier, because there is so much visual movement material available now via the internet.

Tip #2 – Use video wisely and don’t be afraid to hit the rewind button. For more about using video wisely, see the next blog.

MoveScape Center

Teaching Observation Tip 1 – Take Time

MoveScape Center

Learning to analyze movement takes time. Because at least 60% of human communication is estimated to be nonverbal and behavioral, everyone has developed his or her own way of seeing and coding movement. That is, everyone possesses body knowledge and body prejudices. Learning to observe movement objectively using Laban’s taxonomy of effort and space necessitates setting aside pre-existing approaches.

In my own development as a movement analyst, I found I “went blank” for a while when first attempting to observe a movement event. I felt as if I wasn’t getting any information or seeing anything, and this was quite disturbing. Gradually I realized that blank period served a purpose. It gave me time to set aside my customary ways of seeing movement. And this readied me to put on my Laban glasses.

Analyzing movement is like any other physical activity – one needs time to warm up. Warming up has two elements. First, the observer needs to relax, to let go of  preoccupations and to go blank, in a sense.

Secondly, the observer needs to begin to focus attention on the movement event to be observed. This initial focus can be soft and fuzzy, a kind of attuning to the movement without attempting to be analytical and precise. Because movement perception involves multiple senses there are many ways for student observers to attune. Several practical ways to attune are demonstrated in the video chapters of Beyond Words.

Attuning opens the gates of movement perception in a gentle way. So my first tip: don’t ask students to see a movement only once and analyze it. Give them some time to warm up, to relax, and to attune to the movement.

Teaching Movement Observation

Observation is the most demanding of all the skills involved in mastering Laban Movement Analysis (LMA). I must confess to being a slow learner. While I have been teaching observation for over 35 years, it has taken me a long time to grasp why so many students struggle and emerge, even after a year of Certificate Program training, still feeling very insecure about using LMA as an observer.

In the following blogs I share 5 tips for teaching movement observation and analysis. Before sharing these tips, however, I want to briefly discuss why observing movement using Laban’s taxonomy is difficult.

Every observer is biased. Adult learners are not blank slates. They have been observing and making sense of movement their whole lives. This means each learner has a way of categorizing movements. These categories are seldom identical with the ones Laban developed. Thus the student must set aside his/her own way of seeing movement to adopt Laban’s system.

MoveScape CenterMovement has “no fixed points.” Movement is dynamic, changeable, and ephemeral. Even a movement sequence that has been “set” will vary a little with each performance. These variations frustrate students, particularly at the beginning. Or as one student complained, “Of course I could observe her movement if only she would hold still!”

Laban’s system is parsimonious. There are only a few categories with which the observer must capture any movement a human being can do. For example, pounding a stake into the ground and passionately embracing someone share the effort quality of increasing pressure, although the actions have little else in common. Laban Movement Analysis requires the observer to draw out or abstract effort and space elements from quite dissimilar movements.

Students must not only see, they must also “be seen.” Because Laban’s system is abstract, it serves admirably as a general approach for describing movements of all sorts. But it takes time for a student to be able to identify the effort and space elements that are common in quite different looking actions. To develop confidence, the student observer must not only see, but also have what he or she is seeing confirmed by a more experienced observer.

Analysis alone is worth very little. No one really wants a movement analysis – they want to improve a tennis serve, find a way to relieve back pain, discern whether a politician is or is not lying. In other words, movement analysis should not be an end in itself. Like any other tool, it should be used purposefully to solve a problem or answer a question. Discovery makes movement analysis relevant.

Revitalize
with Body, Effort, Shape, Space, and FRED

OK, I’m kidding.

Cate Deicher and I are not going to talk about FRED in the Revitalize workshops on Saturday, December 6th, in New York City. Instead, we will be sharing our novel views of BESS (Body, Effort, Shape, and Space) in these exciting refreshers for certificated Laban Movement Analysts.

Why are these refresher workshops unique? Because over the past decade, I’ve been integrating original material based on my research in the Rudolf Laban Archive into my LMA classes. Meanwhile, Cate has been pioneering new approaches in her work with unconventional students of LMA – artists, designers, architects, and nurses.

If this is not enough to pique your curiosity, here are five more reasons to attend Revitalize December 6th.

1) We have created a workshop schedule that you can customize to fit your time and energy.

2) The workshops are affordable. The more you do, the more you save.

3) Revitalize and the other Meaning in Movement workshops take place in a beautiful and easily accessible studio in midtown Manhattan.

4) It is a rare opportunity to study with Cate and myself, since we usually teach exclusively in the Midwest, West, or overseas.

5) As a teaching team, we rock!

Find out more about Revitalize and the whole Meaning in Motion weekend of workshops…

MoveScape Center